Asking people to Google their questions about LGBTQ people is risky
If you're a member of the LGBTQ community, chances are you've been asked the same questions over and over. Did someone or something make you gay? What does transgender even mean? Why do there have to be so many pronouns?
It's exhausting, especially because most people's knowledge of the LGBTQ community is limited to what they learned on the playground and a viral clip of Ben Shapiro. No wonder the newish allyship guides have encouraged people to Google their questions about the LGBTQ community, instead of relying on the marginalized to do the work of explaining.
It's a reasonable request. If only Google and the platforms were up to the task.
SEE ALSO:All the best queer memes inspired by NintendoWhen Bustle interviewed 19 members of the LGBTQ community last year about how allies can improve, participants came up with similar answers: "A big one was not relying on LGBTQA+ people to educate you on the issues when Google is a thing — and it's free. Be conscientious of the emotional labor that goes into constantly explaining thingsto and do your own research."
DIY research is a great idea, but the problem is, Google isn't always the best teacher. As the 2016 election (and its aftermath) have taught us, searching out good sources is a skill, one that largely comes with education. Too often, even well-intentioned readers aren't capable of separating good news sites from bad ones, or Russian bots from real people.
Take a look at what happens when you Google common questions about the LGBTQ community. This is the very first Google search result from "What does the rainbow mean?" It comes from DesiringGod.org:
Surprisingly, this is not accurate.Credit: screenshot/desiring GodI Googled "Can you cure homosexuality?" and this was the seventh result I found, from the famously anti-LGBTQ organization, Focus on the Family:
OK.Credit: screenshot/focus on the familyThe first result for the question: "Why is my kid gay?"is also from Focus on the Family.
I was diagnosed with pre-homosexuality and current-homosexuality and will likely develop forever-homosexuality.Credit: screenshot/focus on the familyImagine what happens after an uninformed person Googles "transgendered" (not really a word, but used by people unfamiliar with/antagonistic to the community) and "predators."
This if the fifth result, from anti-LGBTQ hate group Family Research Council:
YouTube is worse, if possible. Here's the fifth result I found when I searched "difference between sex and gender." It's from notorious enemy of the queer and trans community, Jordan Peterson:
No one should ever take their opinions from this man.Credit: screenshot/youtubeThen there are the fourth and fifth results after I search "What is the gender binary?" on YouTube ... of course Ben Shapiro had something [wildly incorrect] to say.
When you want to debate this late into your thirties, something's wrong.Credit: screenshot/youTubeThe problem is pervasive, but the explanation is simple: Search engines aren't designed to be culturally sensitive. They share and incidentally prioritize plenty of malicious content. Google the company might consider itself an ally to the trans and queer community, but Google the search engine is not.
"One component of the algorithm looks at the number of links to a webpage to determine how high a website appears in a search, and this puts LGBTQ advocacy organizations and community groups at a disadvantage, as sensationalized or malicious content will often have a larger audience," Chris Brown, Digital Director at GLAAD, told Mashable. "Online spaces have always been places where LGBTQ people are able to make connections and build community ... Unfortunately, oftentimes we find this positive content flagged for removal, while malicious content is able to proliferate algorithmically with limited checks and balances."
People are emotionally complex. So are their questions. It can be a challenge for search engines to provide them with the nuanced answers they deserve, Oliver Haimson, a President's Postdoctoral Fellow at the University of Michigan's School of Information, explains:
"The problem here is that Google's goal is to provide information that best matches a text query, and that goal may be at odds with the complexities that arise when people have questions about the LGBTQ people in their lives. Google's algorithms tend to promote content that is linked to and clicked on a lot, but otherwise do not always do a great job of distinguishing between helpful advice and harmful/inaccurate advice. This type of algorithmically curated search result may not be a good stand-in for advice for a distressed parent who is just learning that their child is gay or trans."
Consider a slightly better scenario: A straight or cis person, seeking answers about the trans and queer community, comes across a site that is actually curated by *gasp* the trans and queer community. Even then, not all of these sites are explainers, and no single one is representative of a larger community. This kind of searching is a risk to the LGBTQ community most of all. Not everyone who posts about their gender identity wants the people in their personal life (or strangers seeking advice on the internet) to view it.
In an ideal world, the algorithms themselves would improve.
"One of my main concerns would be straight and/or cis people coming across content that was not meant for them, possibly even by people in their own networks," Haimson says. "For example, if a cis ally went digging too deep, she may uncover a friend or family member's trans or non-binary identity that that person was not yet ready to disclose to her ... LGBTQ people may feel comfortable sharing more personal information within these communities and online spaces that they think are not going to be accessed by outsiders. When outsiders access these communities, it breaks that trust."
Cultural education isn't easy, no matter the venue. People who are curious about the LGBTQ community should be given the opportunity to learn about the community without resorting to misinformed or malicious actors on the internet. And people who are tired of answering the same three questions about their gender identity and sexual orientation shouldn't have to answer them.
In an ideal world, the algorithms themselves would improve.
"Any possible solution to bias in machine learning will require community involvement, and a seat at the table for LGBTQ people and experts when product decisions are being made," Brown says.
In a less-than-ideal world (i.e the one we currently live in), other solutions will have to do. Here's what Haimson recommends:
"A better scenario would be if there were an online community of allies that LGBTQ people could refer their friends and family members to — that way, humans could learn from each other in safe online spaces."
This shouldn't be hard. Safe online spaces, good information, and people learning from each other: it's a whole lot better than a Google search. Imagine that.
Featured Video For You
Water will never be boring again with this infuser bottle
(责任编辑:行业动态)
- [LLG] When compassion meets law: Lawyer defends goats, dogs, other helpless animals
- Bach insists on neutrality in face of boycotts
- GPS trackers for kids exposed real
- 20 TikTok accounts that will fill the void Vine left in your heart
- Webb scientists haven't found a rocky world with air. But now they have a plan.
- Best smart home deals this week
- Moderna delays once again threaten Korea’s vaccine rollout
- 避开九大操作误区 拥有良好驾驶习惯
- 20 TikTok accounts that will fill the void Vine left in your heart
- Yoon touts pension reform drive amid stagnant popularity rating
- 避开九大操作误区 拥有良好驾驶习惯
- Video shows LG Wing's rotating secondary screen in action
- 我在广西融水有个“园”!庭院经济让方寸地变致富园
-
Input devices like keyboards have a key role in the computing and gaming landscape, so the guts of t ...[详细]
-
GPS trackers for kids exposed real
If there's anything worse than picking an easy-to-hack password, it's being assigned a default easy- ...[详细] -
North Korea's media shifts stance, questions effectiveness of COVID
Staff disinfect the premises of a medical oxygen factory to curb the current COVID-19 health crisis ...[详细] -
All the best signs from Women's March events around the country
The Women's March is back for its third year, and despite several layers of controversy surrounding ...[详细] -
Kenneth Dillon ,August 1, 2024 Pragmocracy ...[详细]
-
The best LGBTQ candidates for 'The Bachelor'
As a queer person, it's long been my dream to see my community represented in the lowest form of ent ...[详细] -
Nearly 1 in 4 recognized victims of toxic humidifier sterilizer products dead: civic group
Keepsakes of victims in the 2011 deadly humidifier sterilizer scandal are displayed on the stairs of ...[详细] -
Who’s next after Nancy Pelosi?
As we stare at better-than-even odds of a House Democratic majority come 2019, we’re also staring at ...[详细] -
本报讯8月23日,中国劳动关系学院劳动关系与人力资源学院副院长张才明一行赴雅考察职工思想政治引领数智化发展工作开展情况。中国劳动关系学院为中华全国总工会和教育部联合共建,是全国总工会唯一一所普通高等院 ...[详细]
-
Military to resume search for Korean War dead
The Army holds a ceremony Friday to mark the resumption of an excavation project to find the remains ...[详细]
- 厚植精神文明沃土 培树司法文明新风
- Teens in MAGA hats sparked outrage at the Indigenous Peoples March
- Two popular camera apps were pulled from Google Play Store
- GPS trackers for kids exposed real
- CeeDee Lamb secures record
- N. Korea's low death count questioned amid COVID
- Gathering rules are slightly eased from Monday: PM