Wayve says self
Why weigh down a self-driving car with a lot of sensors, HD maps, and equipment when you don’t have to?
That's the philosophy of British startup Wayve. It claims it only needs a camera, GPS tracker, and a powerful computer to be able to drive anywhere autonomously.
But experts who specialize in sensing technologies like light-based LiDAR and radar say the idea mostly comes across as preposterous -- or the very least, short-sighted.
Most self-driving cars decide how to drive down a street as it happens -- picking up information about debris in the way, pedestrians on the sidewalk, the sun starting to set in the distance. Wayve doesn’t try to interpret that much data since it can’t really pick up much from its cameras. Instead it relies on training data already plugged into the system and information from past driving experiences, along with any “reinforcement” data, which is any information about the street from the human driver.
In a blog post about its human-driven method, the company said last week it knows its system takes a different and slower approach: "With each safety-driver intervention, our system learns and will improve, rather than buckle with scale. It will take us longer to reach our first deployment, but we are riding a fundamentally different curve."
The experts Mashable talked to, however, didn't think it was a great idea.
"It's lunacy," said Rick Tewell, COO at Velodyne LiDAR. "AI performs a lot better with a lot more data than less data."
SEE ALSO:People still fear self-driving cars a year after Uber fatal crashSelf-driving cars ultimately need reliable, strong data sources to increase safety. Cost is certainly an issue, but as more of the sensing equipment is manufactured, the cost goes down. A LiDAR system used to be thousands of dollars only a few years ago. It's already down to about $1,000 or less. Radar tech is even cheaper.
In terms of cost, Wayve says its sensor and computing costs are 10 percent of "traditional approaches." But for car makers veering into autonomous vehicles and well-funded startups, saving some money for a simplified system isn't a priority.
LiDAR sensors guide this autonomous vehicle.Credit: voyageLeilei Shinohara, vice president of R&D at RoboSense, doesn't understand why you wouldn't want everything sensors can provide. "Sensors can get details that the human eye can't," he said in a phone call from China.
Even if you only have a LiDAR sensor as a safety redundancy, you want to have that on the vehicle -- another fatal Uber or Tesla Autopilot crash has to be prevented. "You may only use LiDAR 5 percent of the time in certain situations if radar fails or is incomplete," but you still want it for those instances, he explained. If a random scenario like a paint truck spilling paint all over a self-driving car happens, cameras and LiDAR sensors might be blocked, but radio-wave sensing radar system will take over.
It all comes down to safety as Matt Weed, Luminar Technologies director of technology strategy, said in a call Monday. Even in all the unlikely "edge" cases, self-driving cars need to be truly driverless and able to handle those moments.
"The whole point of self-driving cars is to be safer than a human driver," he said. Why you would eliminate technology that maximizes safety inputs doesn't compute, "You want to be able to get as much good information about the world as you can."
So much to take in.Credit: LuminarRaviv Melamed, CEO and co-founder of radar sensor company Vayyar Imaging, said in a call Monday from Israel, that the more sensing and perception systems the better -- even if it's a combination of cameras, LiDAR, and radar packages.
"People understand you have to have robustness if you want to have safety" for self-driving cars, he said.
It's that desired robustness that clashes with Wayve's simplified self-driving outlook. You can almost envision Wayve's method as new teen driver with no experience getting behind the wheel compared with a practiced driver trying to improve and become more skilled. Both ways might get us to computer-driven cars eventually, but one way seems more likely to ease a skeptical public, wary of self-driving technology.
UPDATE: April 12, 2019, 9:31 a.m. PDT Wayve co-founder Alex Kendall responded with more details on the Wayve method and computer vision.
He explained that the company's machine learning system can work with any sensor set -- or none at all. "The most important part is that we use end-to-end machine learning to make decisions and drive the car," he wrote in an email.
For him, it's about capturing quality data rather than volume since "not all data is equal."
Featured Video For You
Stanford’s automated car learns to handle curveballs like a pro
(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- Yoon, US Senate's armed service committee chief discuss alliance, N.K. threats
- S. Korea, UN disarmament office to hold joint conference on emerging weapons technologies
- Health authorities begin last
- Police investigate cause of deadly fire at Gunpo apartment
- Apple Watch 10 rumors: Everything we know so far
- 微视频广东:在推进中国式现代化建设中走在前列
- [News Analysis] Experts weigh in on aftereffects from N. Korea’s full COVID
- What Intel's 10th
- Twitter to start monitoring users outside of Twitter, will ban people affiliated with hate groups
- 两个改造提升项目进入收尾阶段
- 7 more soldiers test positive for COVID
- 广东援疆护航“疆品南下”,63家喀什和兵团三师企业亮相广交会
- Predicting the next revelations about Donald Trump Jr.’s meeting with a Kremlin
-
PRE-ORDER NOW: The new Google Nest Learning Thermostat (4th gen) is now available for preorder at Am ...[详细]
-
Desperate farmer destroys rare Lion King toy on live TV to make a point about online bullying
On Friday morning, Australian time, a farmer went on live TV and took a pair of kitchen scissors to ...[详细] -
(Yonhap)Health authorities on Tuesday vowed to guard against potential threats of the new coronaviru ...[详细]
-
“欢乐大舞台”致敬劳动者4月27日,由市文化馆主办的2017欢度“五一”文艺演出,在市文化馆举行。由我市各艺术团体编排的节目,充分展示了人民群众活力饱满的精神状态。精彩的演出获得观众阵阵掌声。演出现场 ...[详细]
-
Apple Watch 10 rumors: Everything we know so far
Apple Watch Series 10, also called "Apple Watch 10" or "Apple Watch X" among tech enthusiasts, shoul ...[详细] -
Guardiola inspires Man City masterclass
LONDON:As Manchester City power towards the Premier League title, the question is not whether Arsena ...[详细] -
[INTERVIEW] 'Medical exchanges should come first in inter
Doctors and officials from government and non-governmental organizations attend a symposium on North ...[详细] -
Guardiola inspires Man City masterclass
LONDON:As Manchester City power towards the Premier League title, the question is not whether Arsena ...[详细] -
24 Museums Dedicated to Black History
TheNational Museum of African American History and Culture opened in Washington, D.C., in 2016. It q ...[详细] -
Pompeo to visit North Korea next week with new special envoy
U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, right, announces former senior executive of Ford Motor Company ...[详细]
- Blinken condemns Russia
- Sheldry Topp went to prison when he was 17 in 1962. It’s time to let him go free.
- 2023年林木品种审定新增35个良种,助力绿美广东生态建设
- [INTERVIEW] 'Medical exchanges should come first in inter
- Tesla considers adding a new ‘stuck detection' feature to Cybertruck. Here’s why.
- 家住正黄附近的市民买茶买酒更方便了
- US tells its citizens not to visit North Korea