Brands have no idea how to deal with being caught in a political firestorm
Coffeemaker wreckage, political pizza purchases, and erratic boycott calls flooded social media this week as major brands struggle to navigate the riptide of America’s culture wars.
Controversies like Fox News host Sean Hannity’s defense of accused sex predator and Alabama senatorial candidate Roy Moore and NFL player protests have once again thrust consumer companies into the middle of loud fights over charged topics like racism in America and society’s treatment of sexual assault.
SEE ALSO:Here's why 'Hannity' fans are destroying their KeurigsTweet may have been deleted
Brands have responded to this activism with all the rigid conviction of an inflatable tube man at a car lot.
Keurig recanted its decision to pull ads from Hannity’s show after the television personality’s outraged fans spent last weekend smashing their 100-dollar coffee machines in protest. Other Hannity advertisers like Volvo and Realtor.com also waffled, tweeting and deleting statements hours apart.
Tweet may have been deleted
Meanwhile, Papa John’s tried to walk back a remark an exec made in a recent earnings call suggesting that NFL national anthem protests had hurt sales.
“🖕 those guys,” the pizza chain tweeted of its neo-Nazi admirers.
Tweet may have been deleted
Papa John's chief marketing officer Brandon Rhoten said the company decided to send the tweet because he claims its stance was being misrepresented in the media.
"When it became obvious that our position wasn’t clear we decided we needed to act," Rhoten said in an email. "Many seem to report what companies say through their own personal bias versus actually looking at the words, both in social and news outlets."
He said the vulgar emoji was added to underscore "how adamantly opposed Papa John’s is to groups of this nature."
Forced into the fray
Discussions of genocidal fascism are relatively new territory for the marketing and public relations arms of chain restaurants.
But they’re now getting more practice. The extreme political chasms blown open by Donald Trump’s election have forced all brands to more frequently take sides on contentious social issues this year, whether it’s spurred by crowds of white supremacists marching in Virginia or Ivanka Trump’s shoes appearing at Nordstrom.
“It’s just an explosion out there,” said branding consultant Dean Crutchfield. “People can vote in the millions just by clicking on things...There’s now lots of ways to hold brands accountable.”
A vigorous boycott movement has emerged to pressure brands to cut ties with the Trump administration, his business empire, and the fringe right-wing media that powered his campaign. Trump-supporting counter-protesters have responded in kind.
The learning curve for businesses in this new environment has been a bit clumsy. On one hand, they’re sometimes eager to associate their brand with fundamentally uncontroversial but emotional progressive values like anti-racism, gender equality, and legal immigration. The commercial breaks of this year’s Super Bowl were blanketed in such messages.
But if enough of their customer base would rather they shut up about those lofty ideals, they’ll do that too.
The result is often an awkward flip-flopping response like those of Keurig, Papa John’s, and others. Brands will test the waters with one message but get spooked by the number of people they anger and move in the other direction.
This reaction is the sort of damned-if-you-do-damned-if-you-don’t prisoner’s dilemma in which nobody really comes away happy. More than anything, consumers see it as disingenuous, and both sides are left with suspicions.
“There’s no study in the world that says that brands benefit from politics,” Crutchfield said. “It’s usually not something that is a good strategy for brands in a typical way.”
In some sense, brand marketers brought this on themselves. Consumer businesses have generally become more vocal about social causes in recent years as market research has shown a millennial appetite for brand activism. Social media has also reshaped the relationship between brands and their customers, and encouraged the former to develop anthropomorphized presences that weigh in on issues of the day.
'Woke' brands
This effort to appear socially conscious has cemented the notion that brands should have moral worldviews beyond selling things and take stances accordingly.
That idea’s now grown out of their control and, sometimes, their comfort level. For all of their touting of gender equality, brands like Volvo or Nature’s Bounty granola would evidently rather not parse the many allegations of underage sex predation against a Senate candidate or Hannity’s complicity in excusing them.
Such are the limitations of conspicuous brand posturing. It’s telling that many of the Trump-related consumer controversies have stemmed not from marketing or PR output but comments made during earnings calls and industry conferences -- venues at which it’s assumed that the audience is mostly shareholders and investors.
Trump’s business-friendly White House stands to benefit Corporate America in all kinds of ways, and the attitudes of the C-suite power-brokers don’t necessarily match those the brand presents to the public.
Some of the brands that pulled about-faces on Hannity’s show explained them away as situations in which social media staffers acted outside of the company’s internal policies, and higher-ups intervened.
Above all else, public-facing companies are controversy-averse by nature.
"This is an unacceptable situation that requires an overhaul of our issues response and external communications policies and the introduction of safeguards to ensure this never happens again," Keurig CEO Bob Gamgort said of his company's original announcement that it would pull ads from Hannity's show.
Above all else, though, public-facing companies are controversy-averse by nature. If enough people are making noise about something -- regardless of what it is -- they’ll usually err on the side of acting fast to make it stop.
But the internet makes it easier to create the illusion of a widespread consumer insurgency or otherwise cynically manipulate this tendency. For instance, a relatively small group of online reactionaries involved in the so-called "Gamergate" movement were able to convince several of now-defunct Gawker’s blue-chip advertisers to suspend business with the site through a targeted campaign in 2014.
High-running emotions
As the willingness to break expensive kitchen appliances might suggest, the debate around Hannity’s behavior is also very emotionally charged. Data from emotion measurement firm Canvs found that people tended to direct a good part of those feelings toward associated brands.
"Unlike most emotional conversations about TV, brands have been raised to the forefront of the discussion surround 'Hannity,'" said Zach Servideo, a media consultant who works on behalf of Canvs. "These brand-driven viewers' emotional reactions are really unprecedented when you look at any show on TV."
A word cloud around discussions of Sean Hannity in emotional terms.Credit: canvsThat's the stuff of marketing nightmares. Brands tend to be as fearful of organic negative emotions accelerating into a viral movement against them as they are obsessed with finding the positive analogue.
So what is a poor, beleaguered brand to do? One solution is to agree upon a set of steadfast moral standards that are independent of short-term market considerations. Then become savvy enough on contemporary issues to understand and evaluate the validity and sincerity of opposing arguments before diving into a controversy headfirst.
Skittles demonstrated how effective this simple approach can be last fall when Donald Trump Jr. posted a tweet comparing the candy to refugees.
"Skittles are candy. Refugees are people. We don’t feel it’s an appropriate analogy," Skittles said in a statement addressing the tweet. "We will respectfully refrain from further commentary as anything we say could be misinterpreted as marketing."
The message was definitive, consistent, and sensitive to the perception that it might be butting into a heavy political discussion to sell candy.
But then again, there's always the middle finger emoji.
The story has been updated to reflect that the name of the firm providing the emotions data was Canvs not iSpot.
Featured Video For You
Here's why 'Hannity' fans are destroying their Keurigs
(责任编辑:产品中心)
- 13 Places to Find Little Legends and Compact Cryptids
- Pennsylvania, Maryland, Connecticut and two other states vote.
- North Korean leader's weight loss leads to diverse speculation
- Chinese police capture North Korean convict on the run
- The Measurers
- 16 of the Most Epic Sandwiches Around the Planet
- Kyrgios tells Murray 'you are better than Djokovic'
- The White House just brutally burned Australia's Prime Minister
- NBC really just greenlit 'Law & Order: Hate Crimes'
- “笋货”上市采购旺!清远西牛麻竹笋迎秋季尝鲜热
- S. Korea, US likely to hold 2nd round of defense cost
- 雅电集团高空作业为输电线路安装避雷器
- Cheating on rise in Korean language tests
-
How much will PCB's Champions Cup mentors be paid?
ListentoarticleThe Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) has appointed five distinguished mentors for the upc ...[详细] -
持续了9天!广西供销大集在大新举办|粤桂协作_南方+_南方plus红岩大地花竞放,木叶传情迎宾来。10月13日—22日,2023年广西供销大集活动暨“庆丰收·促和美”农民丰收节活动在大新县金桂·德天印 ...[详细]
-
North Korea bashes UN human rights council over 'arbitrary' standard
people bow to the portrait of North Korean leader Kim Jong-un in Pyongyang, Nov. 18, in this image c ...[详细] -
President Moon Jae-in delivers a speech during a ceremony to mark the 20th anniversary of the founda ...[详细]
-
Sinkhole swallows up car, injuring 2 in Seoul
A sinkhole has swallowed up a car on a road in Seoul's Seodaemun-gu, on Thursday. (Yonhap)A sin ...[详细] -
雅安日报讯近日,石棉县人民法院公开开庭审理了一起寻衅滋事案,被告人杨某因犯寻衅滋事罪,当庭被判处有期徒刑八个月。2014年12月20日,杨某等人酒后来到石棉县公安局门口,借着酒劲走上前使劲推公安局玻璃 ...[详细]
-
雅安日报讯近日,石棉县人民法院公开开庭审理了一起寻衅滋事案,被告人杨某因犯寻衅滋事罪,当庭被判处有期徒刑八个月。2014年12月20日,杨某等人酒后来到石棉县公安局门口,借着酒劲走上前使劲推公安局玻璃 ...[详细]
-
'Maddening' Bulls dynasty couldn't seek '99 crown: Jordan
NEW YORK:Michael Jordan believes the Chicago Bulls 1990s NBA dynasty would have stayed together for ...[详细] -
Best CPU Deals, AMD vs Intel: Holiday CPU Buying Guide
Earlier this week, we looked at GPU pricing and the market to see what sort of prices would truly co ...[详细] -
The White House just brutally burned Australia's Prime Minister
If Australia thought it mattered to the new U.S. administration, the message is now loud and clear: ...[详细]
- Yoon touts pension reform drive amid stagnant popularity rating
- Player divide threatens Premier League's restart plan
- Marvel wanted Wakandans in 'Black Panther' to have British accents
- Tech dominates ranking of the world's most valuable brands
- 21 Caves That Offer Otherworldly Experiences
- 急诊急救 托起更多人生命的希望
- 'Maddening' Bulls dynasty couldn't seek '99 crown: Jordan