The depressingly futile shadow war between Iran and Israel.
Iran’s drone strike on an Israeli-owned oil tanker last week was but the latest in a series of skirmishes between the two states in the past two years—though it also marked a dangerous escalation, in which both sides are taking higher risks but achieving no apparent gains in their security.
The attack may have been retaliation for an Israeli attack on an Iranian military vessel in April, which may have been a response to an Iranian attack on an Israeli-owned container ship in March…and on and on the trail of tit-for-tat attacks goes, at least back to the summer of 2019, when Israel attacked a ship carrying Iranian oil and arms through the eastern Mediterranean and Red Seas—in violation of sanctions that were re-imposed when then-President Donald Trump after he withdrew from the 2015 Iran nuclear deal.
In the two years since, Israel has launched at least 10 attacks on Iranian vessels. It is not known how many times Iran has attacked Israeli vessels, as Iranian spokesmen have denied involvement in any of the strikes and Israeli officials have often declined to acknowledge that the strikes—which demonstrate Israeli vulnerability—occurred.
In any case, rancor over the Iran nuclear deal lies at the heart of this new cold war at sea. Benjamin Netanyahu, Israel’s prime minister until his party lost June’s elections, was instrumental in convincing Trump to scuttle the deal—and then hyperactive in keeping President Joseph Biden from reviving it when he took over the White House in January. Congressional Republicans (and several Democrats as well) always despised the nuclear deal; Biden was keen to seek bipartisan support for a number of other contentious issues when he first gained office, and so put restarting the deal on the back burner. In the interim, Netanyahu stepped up attacks on Iran—knowing that Iran would strike back, which would make a new nuclear deal still more unpalatable politically.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementOn April 6, hours before U.S., Iranian, and European diplomats assembled in Vienna to reopen talks on the nuclear deal, an elite commando unit of the Israeli Navy attacked an Iranian military vessel. The next day, to drive the point home, Netanyahu said, “The deal with Iran that…threatens our destruction will not obligate us.”
The number of Israeli attacks rose considerably after Trump’s electoral defeat in 2020. As a result, speedboats manned by Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) began to escort tankers through the Red Sea, then hand them off to Russian naval escorts—from a distance—through the Mediterranean. The Israeli attack in April occurred while the Russian ships were too far away to respond.
AdvertisementThroughout this game of tit-for-tat, Israelis and Iranians have taken care to minimize damage, usually aiming to hit (in some cases, attaching mines to) sections of the ship that would damage but not sink the vessel. However, last week’s Iranian attack on the oil tanker—owned by Israeli shipping magnate Eyal Ofer—killed two crewmen, one British, one Romanian. Iranian spokesmen have denied involvement in the strike, as they have after every attack. But Iran’s leading ultraconservative publication, Kayhan, acknowledged the deed, claiming that the Israeli vessel was a “spy ship”—unlikely, since Israel has plenty of intelligence assets in the region without having to use a commercial ship as cover.
AdvertisementBoth sides know that they are playing a risky game. Hossein Dalirian, a military analyst affiliated with Iran’s IRGC, recently told the New York Times, “We are at war but with our lights out.” A “senior Israeli diplomatic source” told al-Monitorthat Israel’s strategy is “controlled escalation,” though the diplomat added, “The problem is that the ability to control deterioration is limited, and you could find yourself deep inside a war at any given moment without meaning to go there.”
Advertisement AdvertisementNations with preponderant military strength tend to fall into this trap when swatting a smaller power, especially when the latter turns out to be more determined or have more at stake. In June, after U.S. fighter jets bombed Iranian-backed militias in Iraq and Syria (in response to the militias launching a drone strike on U.S. troop-positions in Iraq), a Pentagon spokesman said the bombing was meant to send “a clear and unambiguous deterrent message”—i.e., don’t attack us again, or we’ll attack you again, harder! The problem is, the militias did attack again—and will always do so, especiallyif the U.S. portraysthe back-and-forth as a contest of determination. As long as the U.S. (or, in the present instance, Israel) isn’t waging all-out war, there’s no reason for Iran to back down—and every reason to keep the attacks going.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementIran is hardly blameless in this escalation. Some of the vessels Israel has attacked have carried not just oil to markets but weapons to militias that pose a threat to Israel’s security. Given the many Iranians (especially the IRGC) oppose reviving the nuclear deal or any friendly ties to the West, it may well be that some of their moves have been provocations for their own sake.
Popular in News & Politics
- A Great American Con Led to the Mess on College Campuses. Everyone Fell for It—Again.
- The Trump Defense Made Hope Hicks Cry. The Prosecution Got What It Wanted.
- There’s One Part of Brittney Griner’s Account of Life in Russian Prison That Really Stands Out
- Only One Thing Will End the Protests—and Relieve Joe Biden of This Gigantic Headache
All three countries—the U.S., Israel, and Iran—have (or, in Iran’s case, is about to have) new leaders. It is possible to shift patterns. But the opportunities for détente are swiftly diminishing. It still puzzles me why Biden didn’t move quickly to re-start nuclear negotiations, taking up an EU offer to mediate a step-by-step process where the U.S. gradually lifted economic sanctions and Iran—once again—gradually cut back its enriched uranium. Now, with a more hardline president about to take office in Tehran and with the Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei declaring (not without reason) that the Americans cannot be trusted, it may be too late. Israel’s fragile new government is in no position to take daring moves toward engaging with Iran.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementMeanwhile, Iran and Saudi Arabia have been holding talks since April—at first in secret, now openly acknowledged—that seem to be on track to some form of rapprochement.
The main topic at hand seems to be ending the brutal proxy war in Yemen, but if broader measures are broached, they could disrupt—and possibly finish off—Saudi Arabia’s alignment with Israel (based entirely on their shared hostility to Iran), which could sour the Abraham Accords that Israel signed with Bahrain and the United Arab Emirates, all of which could shatter Israel’s security.
Shia and Sunni are as unlikely as lions and lambs to make peace and lie down together, but the region’s politics are shifting in one way or another, and by playing their games of “controlled escalation” and “deterrent messaging”—focusing too much on tactics, not enough on strategy—the United States and Israel are losing control of the story, shooting themselves in their heels.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- SpaceX Polaris Dawn mission: How to watch the launch
- 13 gifts for people with acid reflux
- Man Utd sale to end Glazers' era
- Djokovic dispatches Tsitsipas in ATP Finals opener
- Scientists discover where the huge dinosaur
- Best Labor Day headphones deals: Apple, Bose, Beats, and more on sale
- Chance the Rapper wins Best New Artist, because sometimes the Grammys are right
- Man Utd sale to end Glazers' era
- Djokovic dispatches Tsitsipas in ATP Finals opener
- Flying spaghetti monster and unworldly life filmed in deep sea footage
- Yoon keeps all options open to counter North Korea's threats
- 知道吗?流浪狗也想有个家
- Truckers go on strike, but no major disruptions reported
-
Spate of defections show Kim Jong
A new monument that commemorates North Korean defectors who have died while escaping from the repres ...[详细] -
England can make 'best' period with World Cup win
LONDON:England manager Gareth Southgate called on his players to shut out the noise ahead of this mo ...[详细] -
Facebook's election 'war room' is now empty
Facebook's vaunted election "war room" is currently empty, but the social network says that doesn't ...[详细] -
河滩上兴起“新”玩法虽然汛期来临,但丝毫没有影响市民到青衣江边玩耍的心情。近日,记者走访青衣江边,发现市民除了钓鱼,坐在江边闲聊纳凉外,又兴起了一种新玩法——沙塑。在天气不错的傍晚,不少家长都会带着自 ...[详细]
-
市民填写献血相关表格8月22日晚,雨城区正黄时代天街广场天桥旁停靠着一辆献血车,身穿红马甲的志愿者们正向路过的市民发放无偿献血宣传手册,不少市民停下脚步,参与无偿献血。这是雅安市中心血站开启夜间献血模 ...[详细]
-
Chrissy Teigen's son and Billie Eilish have both been turned into a very familiar meme
Celeb couple Chrissy Teigen and John Legend's son Miles is becoming his own meme thanks to a funny r ...[详细] -
Hugh Grant knocking on doors in the name of Brexit is giving us 'Love Actually' vibes
The last time Hugh Grant went door-knocking, he was a prime minister looking for love. But, 16 years ...[详细] -
'Infinity War' teaser puts Avengers, Spider
Marvel has thrown down the gauntlet.Avengers: Infinity Warhas started production at Pinewood Studios ...[详细] -
Apple to start manufacturing iPhone Pro in India, report claims
The first iPhone Pro models to be made in India could be coming as soon as September or October this ...[详细] -
雅安日报讯 昨14)日,记者从宝兴县委农工办获悉,今年以来,宝兴县强力推进新农村示范片建设,将其与灾后重建、乡村旅游、城乡环境综合治理、农村基层组织建设相结合,取得明显成效。该县加强校企合作,利用院校 ...[详细]
- Project 2025 Comstock Act: Trump’s new abortion comment exposed.
- Peloton Wife returns in ad for Ryan Reynolds' Aviation Gin
- Men caught distributing 30,000 items of online child porn
- Nelly Korda regains number one ranking
- 13 Astronomical Clocks Connecting Time And Space
- No alcohol sales permitted at Qatar's stadium – source
- BarkBox is aware their dog toy looks like a Fleshlight