Rental bidding startup seems good for landlords. Tenants? Not so much.
Finding a place to rent can be hellish, but does transferring that process online make it better? One startup argues yes, but tenancy advocates are doubtful.
Alex Lubinsky, the CEO of the Californian company Rentberry, is aggressively confident about the usefulness of his product. He even characterised the heavy criticism levelled at it in the U.S. as "good publicity."
His site allows prospective tenants to make offers against others to secure properties. While Lubinsky would prefer those offers be called "custom submission," it's not hard to see why it's been called an "eBay-style" platform on which tenants will rush to outbid each other, potentially pushing prices to new heights.
If the landlord accepts, the tenant then pays Rentberry A$25, although the company has floated changing that to a percentage model.
SEE ALSO:A floating techno-libertarian city might be coming to the PacificThe startup launched in 10 cities across the U.S. in 2016, and is now rolling out to at least 1,000. First reported by Domain, Rentberry has announced its intention to launch in Australia. With no set launch date, Lubinsky said he also has his sights set on Canada and the UK.
There's plenty to fix about renting, no doubt. Attending a house inspection, filling out a form and rushing to the real estate agent's office all in one day is de rigueur. Some automation wouldn't hurt. And it's not uncommon in Sydney for potential renters to offer the landlord a little more rent each month to secure a lease.
Ned Cutcher, senior policy officer at the Tenants Union of New South Wales, acknowledged such a situation is happening "on the sly." Still, he doubts Rentberry is the solution.
"This idea sells itself on making that transparent, but I don't think that's the right response," he said. "The secret business of pushing up rents doesn't notpush up rents by taking the secret out."
Lubinsky claimed the site in fact had the opposite effect over nine months in its 10 launch cities, saving tenants 5.1 percent on rent.
However, Toby Bozzuto, CEO of the real estate development company Bozzuto Group, told the Wall Street Journalthose numbers might be helped along by an oversupply of apartments across the U.S. In Australia, the situation may be different. Sydney, for example, is reportedly dealing with oversupply in some suburbs and undersupply in others.
"I'm not convinced of how encouraging people to bid up a price brings that price down."
Tenants saved money because landlords want the most qualified, trustworthy people as their renter, Lubinsky argued. "When somebody submits an application, landlords, they are not eager to take the highest bidder. Everyone knows this, but people disregard this and say, 'oh, it's all about money' -- well, it's not," he said.
Cutcher, however, was was unconvinced. "Scarcity is a key factor. If you've got more people who are looking for properties than there are available, the only real impact this can have is pushing rents up," he said. "I'm not convinced of how encouraging people to bid up a price brings that price down."
Rentberry also forces transparency on the renter that's not quite expected of the landlord. There are fears, raised by Grist, that user profile pictures could prompt landlords to racially discriminate against prospective tenants. Lubinsky, for his part, dismissed that, suggesting users could use cartoon avatars if they wished.
In the U.S., the company also supplies the applicant's credit score and background check results to the landlord, but he could not disclose which companies it would be working with in Australia to provide those details.
The tenants, of course, don't see quite as much information about their landlord. What if they're notorious for letting properties fall into disrepair, for example? Lubinsky suggested the ability for tenants to review and rate landlords after they leave will take care of that.
Either way, as many have noted, it's clear landlords have the power. If they chose to use Rentberry, tenants may be forced to follow them there.
Featured Video For You
Old-school arcade games have made a comeback at this underground gaming tournament
(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- SCOTUS: The courts implementing Project 2025, without Trump.
- 站好疫情“前哨岗” 守住疫情“防护门”
- Trump pardons Anthony Levandowski, who stole trade secrets from Google
- Three talking points from EPL weekend
- Apple Watch bands: 5 favorites to consider as Apple Watch 10 looms
- N. Korea test
- Apple temporarily closing more stores in three states due to COVID
- Instagram Feed videos now have auto
- Trump and Hillary’s emails, Rudy Giuliani and Trump’s lawyers, Hong Kong vs. China.
- Scientists discover where the huge dinosaur
- On summit diplomacy on the Korean Peninsula
- Woods huddling with PGA players over LIV split
- 雅职院召开新型冠状病毒感染的肺炎疫情防控工作第二次领导小组会
-
Webb telescope discovers 6 rogue worlds. They didn't form the way you'd expect.
Sometimes, planets go rogue. Scientists used the powerful James Webb Space Telescope to spot six of ...[详细] -
After tech behemoths like Twitter moved to ban Trump and thousands of other far-right accounts, mill ...[详细]
-
雅安日报/北纬网讯1月29日下午,石马社区党群服务中心走进一位男青年,他拿出一盒口罩、五瓶消毒水对社区工作人员说:“现在举国上下都在众志成城抗击疫情,你们为疫情防控工作放弃休假、日夜忙碌外出巡查,我觉 ...[详细]
-
Liquid salt greases wheels of high
Scientists at Japan's Tokyo Metropolitan University have taken aim at a common problem plaguing next ...[详细] -
Campbell highlights Washington Declaration amid security concerns over Putin
U.S. Deputy Secretary of State Kurt Campbell, center, speaks during a joint press conference at the ...[详细] -
N. Korea’s denial of arms transfers to Russia suggests fears of tougher sanctions: experts
Kim Yo-jong, North Korean leader Kim Jong-un's sister, is seen in this file photo. YonhapMinistry of ...[详细] -
雅安日报/北纬网讯2月8日,正值元宵节,天气阴冷,雅安市人民医院第二院区门口,该院儿科医生马补古正坐在一个临时搭建的“棚子”里。原来,这是医院设在大门口的体温监测点。一张桌子、两把椅子、一个烤火炉,这 ...[详细]
-
Why is Australia’s Scott Morrison so eager to help Trump?
Recently in The World The Day Most Important to Understanding the Israel ...[详细] -
Upgrade Your Monitor, Not Your GPU
Stop! If you're thinking of upgrading your gaming PC setup, don't buy that overpriced graphics card ...[详细] -
Donald Trump impeachment, Ukraine, Democrats, starting your own podcast.
Popular in News & Politics Jack Smith Basically Has One Option to Sa ...[详细]
Eng name ODI, T20I squads for Aus series
Apple temporarily closing more stores in three states due to COVID
- 25 Years Later: A Brief Analysis of GPU Processing Efficiency
- Liquid salt greases wheels of high
- Tumblr lets you remove ads by paying a subscription fee
- Julián Castro for Speaker of the House.
- 50 Places to Eat and Drink Before You Die
- 公共场所这样的坐姿不文明
- Trump defends call with Ukrainian leader, calls for Biden investigation.