Facebook just became the ultimate dystopia
When constructing a dystopia, it takes some doing to be both Orwellian and Huxleyan at the same time. But with the changes he just announced to the Facebook News Feed, Mark Zuckerberg seems to have managed this extraordinary feat.
The nightmare worlds of George Orwell (Nineteen Eighty-Four) and Aldous Huxley (Brave New World) are in many ways polar opposites. One is a surveillance state that controls what people see of history by literally rewriting newspapers. The other controls its citizenry by blissing them out on a dissociative drug called soma.
SEE ALSO:Facebook announces a big News Feed change — and just wants you to be happyIn his ongoing effort to "improve" Facebook, Zuckerberg is now trying both tactics. He's reducing your access to real news -- in the 20th century, we used to call that censorship -- while increasing the likelihood that you'll only see the outrageous fake news posted by your crazy uncle. Because hey, content posted by family makes you happy, and we only want you to be happy, right?
The algorithm, we already knew, watches you as closely as Big Brother ever did. Every friendship, every like, the length of time you spend reading a story, whether you interact with it -- all of this goes on your permanent record. (At least with the telescreens, Orwell told us, you knew they weren't watching the wholetime.)
At least you knew when telescreens were watching.Credit: Moviestore/REX/ShutterstockThe fact that Facebook is going to simply show you less news makes it more efficient than Orwell's totalitarian state. Party bosses at the Ministry of Truth must be slapping their foreheads: get billions of people to consume their news via social media, then simply eliminate that news content? No rewriting of The Times, no memory hole required, just make the news vanish digitally? Why didn't we think of that?
A brief reminder of why this matters. As of August 2017, according to the Pew Research Center, 67 percent of Americans got their news on social media -- a 5 percent increase from the previous year. On Facebook, 68 percent of users got their news from the site. For the first time in the Pew survey, a majority of Americans older than 50 turned to social media services for news.
To become such a major source of information so fast, and then to simply yank that news away, isn't just an outrageous abnegation of civic responsibility. It's straight out of the dystopian playbook.
An oft-forgotten part of Orwell's oft-mischaracterized classic: the vast majority of Oceania's society, the Proles, weren't given any news at all, not even the fake kind. They were kept happy on a constant diet of cheap songs and lurid stories. Facebook has now gone the Party one better: feeds will likewise be full of equally crappy, thin-gruel content, but the Proles will be producing it themselves. And Facebook gets to monetize it!
Brave New News Feed
"The warm, the richly coloured, the infinitely friendly world of soma-holiday. How kind, how good-looking, how delightfully amusing every one was!" -- Aldous Huxley, Brave New World
Replace "soma-holiday" with "social media," and you can see why Huxley was even more prophetic than we've given him credit for.
The fictional drug soma made you social. It made you feel connected with friends and strangers alike -- in a supremely false way. It took you on what the book's characters repeatedly describe as a "perfect holiday."
The Facebook that Zuckerberg now seems to be envisioning will do the same. People present their best selves on the service; they post carefully curated photos of their "perfect" vacations. And now they will be able to do so without any of that nasty news intruding!
"The research shows that when we use social media to connect with people we care about, it can be good for our well-being," Zuckerberg wrote. He forgot to mention the research that shows Facebook actually makes you more depressed when you're looking at other people's vacation snaps or pictures of their perfect babies.
Like in some kind of twisted experiment, however, we keep hitting that lever
No matter how much you care about the person in question, Facebook invites comparison -- which in turn leads to status anxiety. We may post "congratulations" in the comments, which the algorithm counts as a huge win. Major engagement points! But what we're really thinking or feeling in the face of these richly colored snapshots -- the sudden amping up of our envy, our self-loathing, our depression -- stays hidden from Facebook's all-seeing eye.
Like in some kind of twisted experiment, however, we keep hitting that lever. Let the soma of Facebook help us annihilate ourselves and carry us away on the perfect holiday of others -- how kind, how good looking, how delightfully amusing they are.
SEE ALSO:I deleted Facebook off my phone and you should tooNow Zuckerberg wants us to stay in that mental state without the horrid intrusion of "passive experience" -- his words for what happens when you're reading or watching anything that makes you sit and think, rather than mindlessly typing "congratulations!"
The worst of it is, Zuck thinks he's being noble. He literally thinks he's "doing the right thing." He wants his infant children to look back one day and say that Facebook saved the world.
Perhaps they will. Because with everyone consuming content on Facebook, with media companies that reach for objective truth driven out of News Feeds and out of business, there will be no one left to point out the inanity of all this fake connection. The next generation of Zuckerbergs may well spend their lives on endless soma holidays.
Congratulations, Mark!
Featured Video For You
Is social media getting in the way of our happiness?
(责任编辑:行业动态)
- We Asked GPT Some Tech Questions, Can You Tell Which Answers Are Human?
- 雨城区组织观看《四川:从悲壮走向豪迈》专题片
- 天全县文化市场实现视频监控管理
- Online preschool is winning more support, but is that a good thing?
- We Bought the Cheapest DDR5 RAM Modules We Could Find, Are They Any Good?
- 21 Lost and Lonely Cemeteries
- 家装案例 小户型装出地中海田园风情
- Alcaraz blasts Paul to set up Fritz clash
- Nigeria avenge shock Guinea
- New Grok response directs users to Vote.gov for election questions
- Less than half of South Korean students think unification is necessary
- 成渝经济区拟建12条城际高铁 成雅高铁名列其中
- Korea to conclude land acquisition for THAAD battery this week
-
Spaceship tech slashes energy usage of existing AC systems
As we experience temperature extremes more often as a result of climate change, it predictably leads ...[详细] -
雅望线警校共育联席会本报讯 2月22日,市公安局雨城区分局孔坪派出所、孔坪中心校、李坝中心校、孔坪中学等单位和学校负责人及安保人员齐聚一堂,在孔坪中学召开雅望线警校共育联席会,共商校园周边安全事宜。会 ...[详细]
-
The best tech to buy (and avoid) on Amazon Prime Day 2019
Amazon Prime Day 2019 is coming! For Amazon's fifth annual summer sale, Prime Day is twoentire days ...[详细] -
Korea to conclude land acquisition for THAAD battery this week
South Korea is expected to conclude the land acquisition for the US advanced missile defense system ...[详细] -
Wordle today: The answer and hints for August 29
Can't get enough of Wordle? Try Mashable's free version nowOh hey there! If you're here, it must be ...[详细] -
Gauff loses out to Potapova power
MIAMI:American Coco Gauff was knocked out of the Miami Open on Saturday after an intense three-set b ...[详细] -
本报讯我市就业训练中心将从3月中旬起开办免费创业培训班,有创业愿望的我市下岗失业人员、大中专毕业生、农民工等各类城乡劳动者均可免费参加。据悉,就业训练中心将采取短期培训的方式,每期课程7至10天,培训 ...[详细]
-
NK leader guides firing drills involving super
This photo, carried by North Korea's official Korean Central News Agency on March 19, shows the Nort ...[详细] -
近日,市委政法委会同市法院、市检察院、市公安局、市司法局,出台《全市政法系统“营造法治化营商环境提升年”责任分工方案》,全市政法系统将围绕全市中心工作,聚焦高质量发展主线,立足政法职能职责,进一步发挥 ...[详细]
-
JOHANNESBURG:Nigeria avenged a humiliating Africa Cup of Nations qualifying loss to Guinea-Bissau th ...[详细]