Supercritical geothermal power: Limitless promise or impossible dream?
Supercritical geothermal power holds the promise of meeting humanity's energy needs for millions of years, but how practical is it? A new analysis by Karthik Subramanian of Lux Research suggests that it may lie somewhere between improbable and impossible.
At first glance, geothermal power seems like a brilliant energy source. It's clean, there's enough heat in the Earth to power civilization for any foreseeable future, and all you have to do is drill down to tap it.
Even better is what's called supercritical geothermal. Conventional geothermal systems work by drilling holes into areas marked by volcanoes or hot springs and tapping the heat by either pumping water into the ground and then extracting the steam or by installing a heat exchanger to heat water inside a closed loop of piping.
This works, but such plants are very expensive to install and there are only a very few places in the world where they can be built. They're also limited in output because they only reach a temperature of about 200 °C (400 °F), which works out to an energy output of 5 MW for a single generating plant.
In practical terms that means geothermal power only accounts for about 0.5% of the world's power output and never grows more than 3.5% in any year.
Supercritical geothermal takes the concept to the next level by either finding pockets of magma near the surface at a depth of as little as 2 km (1.2 miles) or seeking the hot inner Earth as deep as 20 km (12.4 miles). Here the temperature and pressure is so great that the water is heated past 373 °C (703 °F) and a pressure of over 220 bars (3,190.83 lb/in², 217 ATM). In this state, the water is superheated, yet is unable to turn into steam. It's also able to hold four to 10 times the energy of regular water or steam.
In other words, a supercritical geothermal plant could have a capacity of 50 MW and three wells could have the power output of 42 conventional geothermal wells. In addition, finding supercritical heat is simply a matter of either finding a magma pocket or digging deep enough in any given location.
That sounds great, but it's a major engineering challenge that pushes drilling techniques and materials to the very edge. Not only must fantastically deep boreholes be dug, they must also be proof against pressures, gasses, and corrosive effects that would quickly destroy any conventional drill rig. However, there's a bigger problem.
In order to get to that lovely supercritical layer or bubble, the drill must pass through what's called the Brittle-Ductile Transition Zone (BDTZ). Put simply, the rock above the supercritical zone goes through a change when subjected to the temperatures and pressures at such a depth. Instead of being brittle, the rock becomes pliable and plastic. Imagine granite that you can roll into snakes like plasticine and you get the idea.
The BDTZ isn't uniform. The upper region is still brittle, the bottom is plastic, and the center is a hybrid of the two. What this means is that it's nasty stuff to drill through, requiring a great deal of effort for very little progress and it's very hard on drill bits and other equipment.
According to Karthik Subramanian, to get through the BDTZ requires a thorough understanding of the drilling area to find spots that are brittle all the way through – if such spots exist. It also means dealing directly with the heat and the corrosive volcanic gasses venting from below, which can include hydrogen sulfide and sulfur dioxide.
In fact, these problems aren't just difficult, they may be insurmountable with current technology, which means that the dream of supercritical geothermal power may remain just that – a dream.
"Supercritical geothermal is far away from commercialization and will depend on advances in drilling methods, digital resource modeling, and materials development to access these resources for power generation," said Subramanian. "Despite its potential, supercritical geothermal will not likely play a prominent role in the energy transition due to its inherent technical impediments. If technical barriers are addressed, supercritical geothermal will be economical only in regions with volcanic or tectonic activity at lower depths unless novel deep geothermal drilling methods prove otherwise."
The problems of deep drilling may mean that supercritical geothermal may be confined to volcanic regions like Iceland or the Pacific Rim of Fire, but getting through the BDTZ may be conquered by the technology being developed by the MIT and Cambridge University-backed Quaise startup. This company plans to use a particle beam generated by a "Gyrotron" that could fracture, melt, and vaporize the offending layer of plastic rock.
How well it could manage it, only time and trying will tell.
Source: Lux Research
(责任编辑:资讯)
- Coach jailed for sexual exploitation of underage athlete
- Mourinho rubbishes 'Spursy' tag despite West Ham collapse
- N. Korea's vice FM, Mongolian president discuss strengthening ties
- Dennis Rodman's North Korea ties have sparked trouble
- Tesla considers adding a new ‘stuck detection' feature to Cybertruck. Here’s why.
- The Techies Who Lunch
- Mourinho rubbishes 'Spursy' tag despite West Ham collapse
- N. Korea's vice FM, Mongolian president discuss strengthening ties
- Mourinho rubbishes 'Spursy' tag despite West Ham collapse
- Families of S. Korean detainees in NK appeal to embassies for support
- South Korea mulls cryptocurrency ban but it's far from finalized
- Man invents tsunami sensor, internet obsesses over his dog
- 教育灾后恢复重建跟踪
-
Carbon neutrality law violates basic rights: Constitutional Court
South Korea's carbon neutrality law does not conform with the Constitution because the absence ...[详细] -
UN dismisses complaint over defectors detained in Seoul
The national flag of North Korea. (123rf)The United Nations Human Rights Committee said Wednesday a ...[详细] -
侨味年货“狂飙”,个个都是“显眼包”| 广东年货大摸底江门篇_南方+_南方plus得益于得天独厚的自然条件江门物产丰富是广东省农业大市也是粤港澳大湾区重要的“米袋子”“菜篮子”“海鲜铺子陈皮、大米、鳗 ...[详细]
-
S. Korea to give 370,000 masks to Koreans adopted overseas
(Yonhap)South Korea will provide 370,000 face masks to Koreans adopted overseas to help them fight t ...[详细] -
Elon Musk's AI facility is reportedly operating gas turbines without a permit
Elon Musk's AI company has caught the attention of environmentalists in Memphis, Tennessee for repor ...[详细] -
Richard Branson: Business leaders are 'baffled' by Trump on climate change
British billionaire Richard Branson said business leaders were left dumbfounded by President Trump's ...[详细] -
Dennis Rodman's North Korea ties have sparked trouble
A human rights group wants former basketball star Dennis Rodman out of the NBA Hall of Fame, thanks ...[详细] -
'I promised my mother': MMA champion Nurmagomedov in shock retirement
CANBERRA:MMA world lightweight champion Khabib Nurmagomedov announced his shock retirement from the ...[详细] -
Yes, big spiders are spreading in the U.S. No, they're not flying.
They're not after you. And they don't "parachute" from the sky.Periodically, people and headlines on ...[详细] -
Facebook's newest tested feature pushes local news and events
As Facebook continues to battle the scourge of "fake news," it's trying out a new feature that it ho ...[详细]
Microwave technique recovers 87% of batteries' lithium in 15 minutes
Record win puts Hamilton's future in focus
- 味道真系正!怀集食材邂逅顺德厨艺
- Dennis Rodman's North Korea ties have sparked trouble
- Facebook became your news diet. Now, it's going to serve you junk.
- This video of a kid getting dizzy at the park is the cutest thing
- South Korean lawmakers brace for US election as Harris, Trump diverge on North Korea
- CES proves that wireless earbuds are the way of the future
- Federer on track for Australian Open