Supercritical geothermal power: Limitless promise or impossible dream?
Supercritical geothermal power holds the promise of meeting humanity's energy needs for millions of years, but how practical is it? A new analysis by Karthik Subramanian of Lux Research suggests that it may lie somewhere between improbable and impossible.
At first glance, geothermal power seems like a brilliant energy source. It's clean, there's enough heat in the Earth to power civilization for any foreseeable future, and all you have to do is drill down to tap it.
Even better is what's called supercritical geothermal. Conventional geothermal systems work by drilling holes into areas marked by volcanoes or hot springs and tapping the heat by either pumping water into the ground and then extracting the steam or by installing a heat exchanger to heat water inside a closed loop of piping.
This works, but such plants are very expensive to install and there are only a very few places in the world where they can be built. They're also limited in output because they only reach a temperature of about 200 °C (400 °F), which works out to an energy output of 5 MW for a single generating plant.
In practical terms that means geothermal power only accounts for about 0.5% of the world's power output and never grows more than 3.5% in any year.
Supercritical geothermal takes the concept to the next level by either finding pockets of magma near the surface at a depth of as little as 2 km (1.2 miles) or seeking the hot inner Earth as deep as 20 km (12.4 miles). Here the temperature and pressure is so great that the water is heated past 373 °C (703 °F) and a pressure of over 220 bars (3,190.83 lb/in², 217 ATM). In this state, the water is superheated, yet is unable to turn into steam. It's also able to hold four to 10 times the energy of regular water or steam.
In other words, a supercritical geothermal plant could have a capacity of 50 MW and three wells could have the power output of 42 conventional geothermal wells. In addition, finding supercritical heat is simply a matter of either finding a magma pocket or digging deep enough in any given location.
That sounds great, but it's a major engineering challenge that pushes drilling techniques and materials to the very edge. Not only must fantastically deep boreholes be dug, they must also be proof against pressures, gasses, and corrosive effects that would quickly destroy any conventional drill rig. However, there's a bigger problem.
In order to get to that lovely supercritical layer or bubble, the drill must pass through what's called the Brittle-Ductile Transition Zone (BDTZ). Put simply, the rock above the supercritical zone goes through a change when subjected to the temperatures and pressures at such a depth. Instead of being brittle, the rock becomes pliable and plastic. Imagine granite that you can roll into snakes like plasticine and you get the idea.
The BDTZ isn't uniform. The upper region is still brittle, the bottom is plastic, and the center is a hybrid of the two. What this means is that it's nasty stuff to drill through, requiring a great deal of effort for very little progress and it's very hard on drill bits and other equipment.
According to Karthik Subramanian, to get through the BDTZ requires a thorough understanding of the drilling area to find spots that are brittle all the way through – if such spots exist. It also means dealing directly with the heat and the corrosive volcanic gasses venting from below, which can include hydrogen sulfide and sulfur dioxide.
In fact, these problems aren't just difficult, they may be insurmountable with current technology, which means that the dream of supercritical geothermal power may remain just that – a dream.
"Supercritical geothermal is far away from commercialization and will depend on advances in drilling methods, digital resource modeling, and materials development to access these resources for power generation," said Subramanian. "Despite its potential, supercritical geothermal will not likely play a prominent role in the energy transition due to its inherent technical impediments. If technical barriers are addressed, supercritical geothermal will be economical only in regions with volcanic or tectonic activity at lower depths unless novel deep geothermal drilling methods prove otherwise."
The problems of deep drilling may mean that supercritical geothermal may be confined to volcanic regions like Iceland or the Pacific Rim of Fire, but getting through the BDTZ may be conquered by the technology being developed by the MIT and Cambridge University-backed Quaise startup. This company plans to use a particle beam generated by a "Gyrotron" that could fracture, melt, and vaporize the offending layer of plastic rock.
How well it could manage it, only time and trying will tell.
Source: Lux Research
(责任编辑:关于我们)
- 让法治建设成效更加可感可及
- Rooftop system converts CO2, water and sunlight into kerosene
- Sam Neill is the daily motivation we badly need during social distancing
- N. Korean hacking group Kimsuky funds Pyongyang's espionage operations through cybercrimes
- Pressure boost squeezes out more hydrogen from artificial leaves
- 雅安市举办首届“文轩教育”校园足球精英夏令营
- Reince Priebus rejects Steve Bannon's touch in awkward TV moment
- Arsenal look to bolster squad in January
- Tokyo Olympics have been postponed to 2021 because of coronavirus
- New image shows the North Star is changing. And it has spots.
- Energizer to launch 26 new phones this month. Yes, you read that right
- Peaceful rally garners attention at home, abroad
- 乘客不良言行谁来监管
-
Unionized hospital workers pull out from strike
Health care workers at Chosun University Hospital hold signs and chant slogans at the hospital' ...[详细] -
This photo, carried by North Korea's official Korean Central News Agency, March 20, shows the North ...[详细]
-
Help us, Star Wars coronavirus memes. You're our only hope.
Our planet is under attack from a deadly enemy the size of midichlorians. Unfortunately, we haven't ...[详细] -
The 'you can only keep 3' meme is here to challenge you in this difficult time
When life gets tough, Twitter often turns to lighthearted memes for some comic relief. But in the mi ...[详细] -
iPhone 16 Pro new color will reportedly be Desert Titanium
Apple's upcoming iPhone 16 Pro will come in a new color, a new report claims, and it will be sort-of ...[详细] -
How coronavirus changed my mind on meditation
March Mindfulnessis Mashable's series that examines the intersection of meditation practice and tech ...[详细] -
雨城区一年满八旬姓代的老人,膝下子孙满堂,儿媳孝顺,这让他感到幸福和满足。前不久,他百般痛爱的13岁孙子代某,为了将他800元钱弄到手,竟伙同一名14岁少年杨某某,将农药投进他的饭菜里……9月2日,雨 ...[详细]
-
Sleep paralysis demon memes are back since everyone's lonely while social distancing
Having trouble sleeping?Hit Snoozeis Mashable's deep dive into how we cope with our collective insom ...[详细] -
近日,市委政法委会同市法院、市检察院、市公安局、市司法局,出台《全市政法系统“营造法治化营商环境提升年”责任分工方案》,全市政法系统将围绕全市中心工作,聚焦高质量发展主线,立足政法职能职责,进一步发挥 ...[详细]
-
Drake reveals his love for Nando's in the most British way
Drake won the award for best international male solo artist at the Brit Awards on Wednesday. But, he ...[详细]
- Kamala Harris’ ridiculous problem with the political press.
- Saenuri dissenters to play key role after scandal
- Here’s why it's so frickin’ hot right now
- Peaceful rally garners attention at home, abroad
- The Best AMD Ryzen Gaming Laptops (So Far)
- 加大城乡结合部敞放犬只整治力度
- National park's prized safety system fails during coronavirus pandemic