The AI stock bubble has burst. Here's how we know.
When you live in tech bubble central, signs of a tech bubble become easier to spot every time. Drive to Silicon Valley on any of the Bay Area's main arteries right now, and you'll notice nearly every billboard pumping a product "driven by AI."
On the same drive five years ago, you'd see the same scene with the word "blockchain." Ten years ago: "big data." Twenty-five years ago: literally any word followed by ".com." Each one in turn, for all its promise, became a punchline.
It's not a question of whether the Silicon Valley machine was wrongon any of these technologies. Especially not the dotcom thing. Heck, the entire internet had just dropped into our laps in the 1990s; you can't blame anyone for dreaming about creating all the stuff we now take for granted. It's a question of impatience: all the investors, startup shysters and panicked CEOs that rush in when a promising new technology emerges are eager for immediate results.
Then reality dawns, as it has evidently done for AI investors this summer. Amid a general stock market downturn Monday driven by the worst one-day crash the Japanese stock market has seen in decades, AI stocks like Nvidia — which delayed its next-gen AI chips, and has reportedly been scraping "a human lifetime" of videos every day for an unreleased AI product despite internal concerns — are taking a beating. Nvidia stock has lost a trillion dollars of valuation, 30% of the total, since its 2024 high.
If history is any guide, and it usually is, there's no coming back from a tipping point like this. The next part will be really painful for a lot of people — and yet more beneficial for longterm tech progress than the bubble mentality could ever be.
How the AI bubble burst
What accounts for the AI vibe shift?
Take your pick. Maybe it was a study revealing that consumers are so turned off by the term "AI," they are less likely to buy a product that uses it.
Maybe it was Sam Altman and his weird unforced error with Scarlett Johansson, or Elon Musk trying to sell a flawed AI chatbot while pushing AI deepfakes.
Maybe it was one of the largest and oldest hedge funds in the world telling clients that AI products are "never going to be cost-efficient, never going to actually work right, will take up too much energy, or will prove to be untrustworthy."
Or maybe it was a Goldman Sachs report on generative AI titled "Too Much Spend, Too Little Benefit?" (That minces words just about as much as one of the best-titled academic papers of 2024, an inquiry into the growing phenomenon of AI hallucination: "ChatGPT is bullshit.")
Tweet may have been deleted
Whatever it was, the signs of panic are everywhere. Tech stocks are getting hammered no matter if they're planning to increase their expenditure — Mark Zuckerberg announced $5 billion in "aggressive" new AI spending on his earnings call last week, then Meta stock dropped as much as 15% the next day — or decrease it to make up for all their AI investments — as was the case with Intel, where $10 billion in cost-cutting tanked the stock 25%.
"Generative AI itself won’t disappear," wrote Gary Marcus, a noted AI skeptic, on his blog over the weekend. "But investors may well stop forking out money at the rates they have, enthusiasm may diminish, and a lot of people may lose their shirts. Companies that are currently valued at billions of dollars may fold, or stripped for parts."
Marcus had previously written that the crash would happen in 2025, but now believes it has arrived months ahead of schedule.
Rather than find revenue on their own, AI startups are suddenly keen to be gobbled up by one of the big fish. A chatbot maker called Character.AI, founded by a couple of AI enthusiasts who left Google because they were frustrated by the bureaucracy, just licensed its product to Google — who will fold the founders and main researchers back into its bureaucracy. In recent weeks, Amazon ran the same acqui-hire playbook on an AI startup called Adept, while Microsoft did it to Inflection.
Could it be any more clear that we've reached an inflection point?
AI's biggest hallucination is being solved
Clearly, there is some promise in generative AI. It's just that much of that promise, as we've said before, lies in the small and boring business tasks: saving a bit of time on code development here, writing the first draft of a document there.
The vision of vast, exponential growth in AI tech, to the point where it is an imminent threat to humanity, should not trouble us much longer. Sam Altman's OpenAI has spent the last two years hyping up this threat; increasingly, Altman is seen as the boy who cried wolf. Large Language Models like ChatGPT have run out of stuff to train on, and the more they are trained on "the internet," the more the internet contains a body of work written by AI — degrading the product in question.
Our excitement about AI art has also popped like a bubble. Everyone has access to the tools — including your family members on Facebook — therefore no AI art is special anymore. Indeed, we're more alert than ever to the shady theft and energy drain involved in making this stuff. AI-generated video is even worse on both counts, and has a harder problem leaving the uncanny valley.
Back in Silicon Valley, what this means is that AI companies and products must have something special to survive the coming correction. Look at the startups that were still standing after the dotcom collapse in 2000 and you'll see some familiar names, like Google and Netflix.
Only if it happens slowly, over many years, without so much venture capital investment creating so much froth, will we finally arrive in the AI future today's startups can only dream about.
This column reflects the opinion of the author.
(责任编辑:产品中心)
-
Secretary of State Antony Blinken speaks during a joint news conference with NATO Secretary General ...[详细]
-
闈掑矝鍥介檯鍟ら厭鑺傗€滃綋浠d功鍧涘悕瀹堕璐轰綔鍝佸睍鈥濆湪宕傚北鍖虹編鏈寮€灞昣涓浗灞变笢缃慱闈掑矝
銆€銆€涓浗灞变笢缃?鏈?1鏃ヨ涓轰簡搴嗚春闈掑矝鍥介檯鍟ら厭鑺備笁鍗佸崕璇烇紝鍑告樉鑺傛棩鐨勬枃鍖栧唴娑靛拰鍝佺墝褰卞搷鍔涳紝鏈眾鍟ら厭鑺傛湡闂寸壒绛栧垝涓惧姙“褰撲唬涔﹀潧鍚嶅 ...[详细] -
服务退役军人,事关强国兴军大业,事关改革发展稳定大局。青岛工行始终秉持“拥军、爱军、崇军”的理念,把服务好现役和退役军人作为服务国防与军队建设大局的重要政治任务,担负好服务部队 ...[详细]
-
11月30日,中国平安举办“平安大讲堂·投资趋势与资产配置策略会”,围绕2023年宏观投资趋势变化、投资挑战和机遇,知名人文财经观察家秦朔、平安银行首席策略分析师 ...[详细]
-
中山古镇:到苏炳添家乡看“村BA”,来一场说走就走的美食之旅
中山古镇:到苏炳添家乡看“村BA”,来一场说走就走的美食之旅_南方+_南方plus小到客厅、卧室、厨房,大到去商超购物、博物馆参观,甚至是在体育馆看一场演唱会……总有一盏点亮你生活的灯,来自这里。中国 ...[详细] -
本报讯9月23日,雅安市政企“面对面”——优化营商环境、构建亲清政商关系恳谈会召开,贯彻落实中央、省、市系列决策部署,围绕优化营商环境、构建亲清政商关系,面对面听取经开区有代表性民营企业负责人的意见建 ...[详细]
-
不少市民期待着,在做好疫情防控的前提下,选择在即将到来的国庆假期出门游玩。雅安旅游资源丰富,拥有41个国家A级旅游景区。在此,记者为广大游客整理了6条适合秋季游玩的精品线路,供大家参考。蒙顶山景区川西 ...[详细]
-
近日,在济南市文化和旅游局、山东省图书馆、山东省图书馆学会的指导下,济南、淄博、泰安、聊城、德州、滨州和东营7市公共图书馆共同发起成立了“省会经济圈城市公共图书馆阅读推广服务联盟&rdqu ...[详细]
-
Cicadas love to land on people. Experts explain why.
Even on an Air Force base tarmac, a cicada landed on the president's neck. The spectacular emergence ...[详细] -
闈掑矝鍥介檯鍟ら厭鑺傗€滃綋浠d功鍧涘悕瀹堕璐轰綔鍝佸睍鈥濆湪宕傚北鍖虹編鏈寮€灞昣涓浗灞变笢缃慱闈掑矝
銆€銆€涓浗灞变笢缃?鏈?1鏃ヨ涓轰簡搴嗚春闈掑矝鍥介檯鍟ら厭鑺備笁鍗佸崕璇烇紝鍑告樉鑺傛棩鐨勬枃鍖栧唴娑靛拰鍝佺墝褰卞搷鍔涳紝鏈眾鍟ら厭鑺傛湡闂寸壒绛栧垝涓惧姙“褰撲唬涔﹀潧鍚嶅 ...[详细]
- [Online Predators] Deepfake pornography haunts S. Korea
- 2024年全国和美乡村篮球组织管理培训班在海南琼海开班
- 鈥滀笘鐣屽浘涔︽棩鈥 闈掑矝骞冲害甯傛柊鍗庝功搴楄喘涔︿紭鎯犲惛鏉ヤ紬澶氣€滅埍涔︿汉鈥漘涓浗灞变笢缃慱闈掑矝
- 鍟ら厭鍩庡彉韬椂灏氳〃婕斿ぇ鑸炲彴锛岃繎鐧惧満娲诲姩绮惧僵涓嶆柇
- 21 Unexpected Wonders in Colorado’s Vibrant Cities and Small Towns
- 2020鍗冲ⅷ鍙ゅ煄姘戣埃瀛e惎骞曪紝鍥藉簡鍋囨湡娣绘皯璋f椿鍔沖涓浗灞变笢缃慱闈掑矝
- 只此青绿,从我做起丨招商银行绿色低碳行动倡议正式发布