Is the “game changer” HiMARS weapons system going to help Ukraine win?
The big news coming out of the war in Ukraine this past month is President Biden’s shipment of a high-tech weapon called HiMARS. It’s been touted as a “very significant factor” on the battlefield, a “game-changer” that has greatly “slowed down the Russian advance.” Is this truth or hype? And what is HiMARS anyway?
On the most basic level, the weapon—first deployed by the U.S. Army in 2005—is what its acronym, fully spelled out, indicates: a High-Mobility Artillery Rocket System. What makes it unlike most artillery rockets—and much more lethal than what the Ukrainian army has had in its arsenal up until now—is that it can fire a wide variety of rockets as far as 50 miles, and, thanks to its GPS guidance system, the rockets can hit their targets with remarkable precision, landing and exploding no more than two to three meters away.
Because of its range and its accuracy, HiMARS has allowed the Ukrainian army to destroy Russian ammunition dumps, command posts, bridges, barracks, and other vital targets well behind Russia’s front lines.
In this sense, HiMARS has leveled the playing field. Until recently, especially in the brutal stand-off in eastern Ukraine, Russian artillery crews could pound Ukrainian positions, while the Ukrainians had nothing with the range to fire back. Now they have something, and the Russians are hurting in ways that they haven’t been hurting before.
AdvertisementBiden, backed by many Western leaders, was initially hesitant to send Ukraine these sorts of weapons because they have the range to strike Russian territory, even from some distance, and therefore might be viewed as provocative. If a U.S.- or NATO-supplied weapon hit Russian territory, Russian President Vladimir Putin might respond by hitting U.S. or NATO targets in Europe—which would escalate the conflict, possibly setting off World War III. However, as Putin kept bombing and shelling Ukrainian civilians well to the west of the battlefield (and after Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky pledged not to hit targets inside Russia), Biden and other Western leaders relaxed their restrictions.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementThe U.S. has supplied 12 HiMARS, with another four on the way. But Zelensky has said he needs 100—and more ammunition to go with them. He’s unlikely to get that many. For one thing, it takes a few weeks to train Ukrainian soldiers how to use these weapons; even now, the U.S. is sending them faster than the Ukrainians can absorb them. Still, faster delivery could bolster Ukraine’s resistance and even help spark a counteroffensive.
AdvertisementIn addition to destroying command posts, bridges, ammo dumps, and other large, fixed targets, HiMARS has also busted up Russian artillery batteries, in some cases a minute after the Russians fired their rockets. U.S.-supplied technology has made this possible: A special radar detects a rocket being fired by a Russian artillery unit, transmits the unit’s latitude and longitude to a data-control network, which directs a particular HiMARS to fire a rocket at precisely that point.
One retired U.S. officer who has been advising the Ukrainians told me, “If Ukraine could do this [rapid counter-firing] more often, Russian [artillery] soldiers would be afraid to go near their guns.” For Ukraine to do this more often, they would need more HiMARS and more rockets for them to fire.
Advertisement AdvertisementThat said, it’s important to note that one new weapon rarely transforms the battlefield irreversibly. Enemies usually counter with a new weapon of their own or with a tactic that adapts to the new situation. The Russians are intensifying their attacks on Ukraine’s heavy artillery pieces—and they have a lot more rockets than Ukraine does. If they had the imagination to do so, the Russians could also disperse their ammunition dumps and place them farther away from the railroad tracks that transport the ammo to the front. (Then again, maybe not: imagination has never been the Russian army’s strong suit.)
AdvertisementPopular in News & Politics
- Sure Sounds Like the Supreme Court Is About to Give Trump a Big Win!
- Trump Is Trying Something New With the 2024 Campaign. It’s Smart—and Terrifying.
- The Most Alarming Answer From Trump’s Interview With Time
- Did That Have to Happen at Columbia? No. Just Look at What Happened at Brown.
There is also the larger geopolitical picture, which is affecting the day-to-day battle more and more directly. Putin has been stepping up his diplomatic game with China, Iran, and Turkey—hoping to turn their converging interests on particular issues into a potent wartime alliance. Xi Jinping has ignored Biden’s pleas to support Ukraine, or at least to stop supporting Russia. After a meeting with Putin just this week, the Ayatollah Khamenei endorsed Russia’s position on the war, supporting the invasion as a necessary preemption to aggression by Ukraine and reportedly sending drones to Russia’s army. Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s interests are mixed—some would drive him to take Ukraine’s side, others might drive him toward Russia’s—but he seems to be drawn to the Moscow-Beijing-Tehran triumvirate, smilingly joining in with the Putin-Khameini powwow despite the backing that Turkey (a member of NATO) has generally given Ukraine.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementPutin is doing all he can to bolster this alliance—his trip to Tehran was only the second time he’s been out of the former Soviet Union since the onset of COVID-19—as a way to hold out for another season in his war.* His aim is to keep up the pressure on Ukraine, grab a bit more territory, formally annex a bit more—then hope that in the fall and winter, when the temperatures plummet, Germany and other European countries will succumb to their dependence on Russian oil and gas, take the fix, and drop out of the “sanctions regime” against Russia—and, with it, the unified effort to support Ukraine.
The brutal stalemate on the battlefield is the cover for a desperate race for time. Which will happen first: Ukraine gets the heavy weapons it needs to turn back the Russian army; or the Western alliance frays and falls apart? The U.S. shipment of HiMARS increases the odds for Ukraine, but this race has many laps and hurdles. It’s not nearly finished.
Correction, July 20, 2022: This post originally misstated that the Iran trip this week was Putin’s first trip outside of the former Soviet Union since the onset of COVID-19. It was his second trip to Iran in that time.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:行业动态)
- Webb scientists haven't found a rocky world with air. But now they have a plan.
- Senator Flake faces dramatic confrontation by survivors
- Paul Manafort: Jail over witness tampering for ex
- North Korea yet to reopen land border with China: unification ministry
- Gastro Obscura's Guide to Where to Eat in Nashville
- Is Mercury retrograde messing with you? Think again.
- Trump's Justice Department sues California over net neutrality law
- 曾在雅安初产龙凤胎 今在卧龙又生龙凤胎
- Scorching heat wave blankets South Korea
- 高燃!哨响表停赛不止,2024广东“村BA”开赛在即,一分钟带你重温高光瞬间。
- US hopes for peaceful resolution of 'Dokdo' row between S. Korea, Japan
- Trump and Kim Jong
- 雅康高速塌方:多功收费站至天全收费站仍双向封闭
-
市民填写献血相关表格8月22日晚,雨城区正黄时代天街广场天桥旁停靠着一辆献血车,身穿红马甲的志愿者们正向路过的市民发放无偿献血宣传手册,不少市民停下脚步,参与无偿献血。这是雅安市中心血站开启夜间献血模 ...[详细]
-
Apple's iCloud could get Face ID and Touch ID support with iOS 13
Apple announced scads of features for iOS 13, iPadOS, and their made-for-computers big sibling macOS ...[详细] -
Google Assistant recordings leaked, and oh boy
It turns out that your private and intimate moments aren't that private after all — if you use ...[详细] -
Pentagon chief arrives in Seoul for annual security talks on North Korea
U.S. Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin / AP-YonhapU.S. Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin arrived in Seo ...[详细] -
Tesla reveals Cybertruck has sold more than DeLorean
If you want to know how many Cybertrucks Tesla has sold, just wait for the next recall. Two months a ...[详细] -
How a remix of 'This is America' became a TikTok anthem for protesting police brutality
A remix of Childish Gambino's "This is America" is now a viral anthem on TikTok used to protest poli ...[详细] -
得知市中级人民法院终审判决结果后,压在何蓝、刘欣夫妇心上的石头终于落地。毕竟,夫妇俩几乎耗尽所有积蓄购买的房子,终于铁板上钉钉,属于自己名下。而败诉的晋浩,只能另行起诉那名“一房二卖”的人,让他退还购 ...[详细]
-
Why Trump headlines make him sound strong and powerful.
Under massive public pressure—from his opponents, from his party, from the world—Trump has signed an ...[详细] -
South Korean lawmakers brace for US election as Harris, Trump diverge on North Korea
Democratic presidential nominee and US Vice President Kamala Harris waves from the stage on Day 4 of ...[详细] -
艾某送来锦旗7月23日下午15时许,雨城公安局特巡警大队走进一位中年男子艾某。当天,他专程来到特巡警大队,将一面印有“破案神速,为民解忧”字样的锦旗送到民警手中,对民警及时为他寻回巨款一事表示感谢。7 ...[详细]
Apple to start manufacturing iPhone Pro in India, report claims
Chelsea's Werner can thrive alongside Lukaku: Tuchel
- Trump trials: Jack Smith is reportedly reconsidering his strategy.
- 广东7个单位、21人拟入选全国农业农村系统先进表彰对象
- Democrats avoid disaster in California, and five other takeaways from “Super Tuesday.”
- Explainer: What are MMX, SSE, and AVX?
- Best smart home deals this week
- US hopes for peaceful resolution of 'Dokdo' row between S. Korea, Japan
- Verona inflict first loss on Mourinho's Roma