Elon Musk defends his right to be a Twitter troll at 'pedo guy' trial
Elon Musk apologized to the jury before reading some of his tweets aloud while testifying in court Wednesday.
"I was calling myself Treelon at that time," he said, explaining an unusual Twitter avatar and name displayed on the screen.
The room tittered, but the brief aside was more relevant to the case than it might seem. This extremely Elon explanation was what he was really fighting for in court this week: the right to keep being a troll on Twitter.
Tweet may have been deleted
Musk is on trial for allegedly defaming Vernon Unsworth, a member of the mission that rescued the Thai boys' soccer team that became trapped in a cave in July 2018. In a CNNinterview, Unsworth criticized Musk's efforts to help — and Musk lashed out on Twitter as a result.
The phrase in that tweetstorm that has since gotten him in legal trouble was referring to Unsworth as "pedo guy." Much of the argument in court centered around whether Musk's words constituted smearing Unsworth as a literal pedophile, or whether he was just slangin' a non-literal insult.
"I thought it was obvious that I was just insulting him."
"People say a lot of things on Twitter that aren't true," Musk said during one of the many discussions about the literal versus figurative nature of Twitter burns. "I thought it was obvious that I was just insulting him."
Whether Musk genuinely believes the defense he and his team are putting forth, or whether he was actually calling the guy a pedophile, is somewhat beside the point. Instead, it was clear from Musk's testimony, his past statements, and his infamous Twitter presence, that he sees the platform as a non-serious free-for-all where he can joke, talk, and troll. One of his lawyers even came up with a new term for Musk's "pedo guy" tweet: a JDART, a joking, deleted, apologized for, responsive tweet. Musk doesn't want legal threats, or his stature as an influential billionaire, to change that for him.
"I would say very little at all if I had to censor what I said publicly," Musk said during cross-examination Tuesday. "Not everything can be completely thoughtful."
Tweet may have been deleted
While the Unsworth insult may have crossed a line (that'll be up to the jury to decide), Musk is a known Twitter troll who doesn't shy away from a fight. On Twitter, he pokes fun of figures like Mark Zuckerberg and bodies like the SEC. He calls out aggressors in plain language like "you're an idiot," and makes stupid jokes about the punning names of his companies and products. It's a persona he relishes.
Even while Musk apparently values Twitter, he has also downplayed the seriousness of the tweets he puts out. At the same time, he sees unfiltered conversation as the superior alternative to what he once described (on Twitter, of all places) as "carefully crafted corporate bs, which is really just banal propaganda."
Tweet may have been deleted
What Twitter represents for Musk is a low-stakes space where he feels he should be able to say what he wants. The Unsworth case challenges that space, by asserting that his words matter, or at least, will cost him if he gets out of turn.
The position Musk appears to be taking — that Twitter is a non-serious place where your words shouldn't be taken literally — is far from settled. Twitter itself is making efforts to reduce trolling, and improve "conversational health." Meanwhile, our Commander and Tweeter in Chief, Donald Trump, reserves the right to lambast his critics, while the courts say the president can't block the people he finds offensive. Beyond Twitter alone, social media companies are split on whether and which lies are OK to live on their platforms, but united in their repeated failures to stem the hatred and slander they do outright forbid. The Musk case, with its many juvenile terms, may sound ridiculous. But the question of whether words and their truth matter on social media,depending on who says them and how far they travel, certainly carries relevance beyond the two parties involved.
Tweet may have been deleted
Musk's lawyers tried to get the judge to nix the Unsworth case. But when that didn't work, Musk actually refused to settle. Why? Musk, a billionaire, probably could have ended the matter with little financial damage to himself. Unsworth initially wanted at least $75,000 in damages, according to court documents, but that number has since ballooned. On Friday, Unsworth's lawyer asked the jury for $190 million.
By seeing the case through to court, and actually testifying himself — for over six hours over two days — Musk is literally taking a stand. Sure, Musk is incredibly wealthy, and his tweets go out to nearly 30million followers. But he wants to be able to say what he wants to say on Twitter, without having to run things by legal and corporate PR for fear of getting sued.
"I get these shakedown letters quite a lot," Musk said, referring to a letter Unsworth's attorneys sent him in August. The testy exchange that followed showed that Musk viewed the efforts by Unsworth and his attorneys as an opportunistic ploy for cash, one that he wasn't going to just let go with an apology and a payout.
Perhaps Unsworth's burn that Musk's building of the mini-sub for the rescue was a "PR stunt" so insulted Musk that he decided this was the "shakedown letter" he decided to take to court.
Or, perhaps, he saw this case a slippery slope, where appeasing the threat of a defamation lawsuit would cost him the freedom of his trolling fingertips on Twitter.
Overthinking his tweets? That wouldn't be Elon — and avoiding that future is what he's fighting for. After all, he isn't a regular CEO. He's a cool CEO.
UPDATE: Dec. 6, 2019, 1:58 p.m. PST This story has been updated with Vernon Unsworth's new request for damages, presented to the jury on Friday: $190 million. In court documents, he initially asked for at least $75,000.
(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- South Korea beefs up drills amid escalating NK provocations
- 奋进跨越促发展 激流勇进谱新篇
- Redditor claims MacBook Pro exploded during 'normal use'
- Park's confidante answers summons for questioning
- Republicans on abortion
- Coach jailed for sexual exploitation of underage athlete
- Unification minister vows to push for reunion of separated families despite NK provocations
- Apple could save music lovers from the disaster that is iTunes
- Court orders govt. to halt nuclear reactor
- SpaceX Polaris Dawn mission: How to watch the launch
- Madrid relying on Benzema for more European glory
- 节能40%,弘科稻谷热泵干燥机高效减损助抢收
- Uber Eats will test food drone delivery in San Diego Summer 2019
-
The Dallas Cowboys and All-Pro wide receiver CeeDee Lamb have agreed on a significant 4-year contrac ...[详细]
-
NK intends to turn Korean Peninsula into Middle East
Unification Minister Kim Yung-ho speaks at the government complex, in Seoul, Jan. 24. YonhapUnificat ...[详细] -
Seoul to build memorial for Korea’s government
The Seoul city unveiled Wednesday a plan to erect a memorial to honor the country’s government-in-ex ...[详细] -
对于中国人而言,过春节的意义重大。不过,如果从经济学的角度来看,却别有一番风味在其中。调查中,多数人对于回家看看更多的感慨是成本,但回家的博弈,买票难的产生,走亲访友能否实现等价交换,回家是否会产生机 ...[详细]
-
味道真系正!怀集食材邂逅顺德厨艺_南方+_南方plus借顺德区举办第46届国际龙家具展览会和第36届亚洲国际家具材料博览会之机,8月19日,怀集县联合顺德区在龙江镇S-Park体育公园举办“怀集味道· ...[详细]
-
数字赋能!“清农网院”助力清远五大百亿农业产业_南方+_南方plus在广袤无垠的清远大地上,一场有关人才与产业的深刻变革正悄然兴起。伴随乡村振兴战略的深度施行,清远市农业农村局积极响应国家号召,遵循政 ...[详细]
-
Huawei cancels laptop launch because of U.S. ban
Huawei has cancelled its planned launch of a new laptop due to a recently imposed U.S. ban that forb ...[详细] -
本报讯 风貌塑造能美化城市形象。昨29)日,记者在市区羌江南路风貌塑造施工现场看到,部分施工楼房的外墙装修已基本完工,“穿”上新衣的建筑看上去漂亮、整洁。经过风貌塑造后,雅安城区将以崭新的面貌迎接新春 ...[详细]
-
On April 8, 2024, the moon’s shadow will completely cover the sun for around three and a half minute ...[详细]
-
N. Koreans celebrate Lunar New Year with traditional food, folk games: state media
North Korean children play folk games at the Kim Il Sung Square on the occasion of Lunar New Year in ...[详细]
Sinkhole swallows up car, injuring 2 in Seoul
This resistance group is sending Trump notes on toilet paper
- CeeDee Lamb secures record
- Uber takes to the skies once more with Uber Copter
- 青铜时代 雅安也很“霸道”
- 给力!华农耕地保育团队积极参与梅州特大暴雨损毁农田灾后修复工作
- 29 Dive Bars, Saloons, and Taverns Where the Vibe Is Unbeatable
- I am so unreasonably jealous of this view of the southern lights
- Craig David's cover of Justin Bieber song is definitely better than the original